Six Star Whey Protein Review: My Personal Experience (2024)

In This Review:
Quick Look | Taste | Cost | Nutritional Value | Mixability | What Other People Are Saying | Comparisons

Prefer to watch than read? Check out my Six Star review on YouTube:

We’ve Tried a Lot of Protein

My team and I have been using and testing protein powders for 5+ years. We are athletes, doctors, and dietitians. We care about what goes in our body and we know you do, too. If you’d like to learn more about our testing process, see here.

A Quick Look at Six Star Whey Protein:

My Personal Experience with Six Star Whey Protein Powder:

Taste Test (6.1)

I tried both the vanilla and chocolate flavors, mixing each with 8 ounces of water, per the instructions.

Vanilla was interesting — it wasn’t quite what I expected. I could taste the artificial flavors and fillers, which meant it didn’t have the pure and clean flavor I was hoping for. It was good, but it wasn’t great. I scored it a 6.2 out of 10.

The chocolate flavor was similar. I was hoping it would surprise me, but it also tasted somewhat artificial. I gave it a 6 out of 10.

Overall, both flavors fell short of my expectations, with the artificial taste being a significant drawback. While the taste was still tolerable, it was subpar compared to other protein powders I’ve tried.

After shaking up the vanilla flavor

Bang for your buck (10)

At a price point of around $20 for an 18-serving container, Six Star Whey Protein is definitely one of the more affordable whey proteins on the market. You’re getting 30 grams of protein per scoop for just over a dollar, which is a great deal. Plus, Six Star often has sales where you can save a few dollars, lowering the price per serving.

However, it’s important to remember that with a lower price tag, you might be sacrificing a bit on quality. As I mentioned earlier, Six Star Whey Protein does contain artificial ingredients that I typically try to avoid in my own diet and when recommending supplements to my clients.

Considering both the cost and the nutritional value, I gave Six Star Whey Protein a 6.8 in the cost category. It’s a solid option if you’re on a tight budget, but what you’re saving in cost you’re likely sacrificing in quality.

Tasting the vanilla flavor

Nutritional value (5.9)

There are some positives to Six Star’s nutritional profile, but it also falls short in a few areas. On the plus side, it packs 30 grams of protein per serving, which is a decent amount if you’re looking to boost your protein intake. It’s also low in sugar, with only 2 grams per serving.

However, the ingredient list is where I have some concerns. Six Star Whey Protein contains a fair amount of fillers and artificial ingredients, which is not something I usually recommend or consume myself. While it does include some added vitamins and minerals like vitamin C (90mg) and zinc (11mg), the amounts aren’t substantial enough to be a significant selling point for me.

That said, I scored the nutritional value of Six Star Whey Protein a 5.9 out of 10. It doesn’t quite meet my standards for a high-quality, nutrient-dense protein powder.

As always, I encourage you to review the ingredient list carefully and consult with a healthcare professional before incorporating any new supplement into your diet, especially if you have any pre-existing health concerns or allergies.

Close up of the ingredient profile

Mixability (6.3)

Regarding mixability, Six Star fell a bit short of my expectations. It was thicker that I expected, even after 15-20 seconds of shaking. The vanilla flavor, in particular, had some noticeable foaming and a slightly grainy texture as I drank it.

The chocolate flavor fared slightly better. I had to shake it for a bit longer to get a more even consistency, but it still wasn’t perfect or as smooth as I would have liked.

Overall, I scored the mixability a 6.3 out of 10. I like my protein shakes smooth and light. But if you don’t mind a thicker texture, you may be just fine with its mixability.

Mixing up the chocolate flavor

What Other People Are Saying

Here’s what other consumers have to say about Six Star Whey Protein elsewhere online:

Positive takes:

• Great taste and easy mixability. Lots of people enjoy the flavor and consistency, especially when blended with milk or water. The vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry flavors were all well-received.
• Excellent value for the price, providing a high amount of protein (30-32g) per serving at an affordable cost compared to other brands. Users appreciate the cost-effectiveness without sacrificing quality.
• Effective for muscle recovery and growth, with users reporting increased strength, faster recovery times, and the ability to meet their protein needs conveniently. The inclusion of creatine and BCAAs was also seen as a plus.

Criticisms:

• Poor mixability and chalky texture, with many users struggling to dissolve the powder in milk or water without clumping. Some found the consistency unpleasant, even when using a blender or shaker bottle.
• Undesirable taste, particularly with the vanilla and strawberry flavors, which some described as artificial, oily, or fishy. A few users also noted a change in the chocolate flavor that made it less appealing.
• Concerns about the ingredient list, including the presence of artificial sweeteners like acesulfame potassium, high fructose corn syrup, and excessive amounts of calcium and iron, which may cause digestive issues for some users.

Six Star Whey vs The Market: How Does it Compare?

As you can see in the below table, I rated Six Star lower than most other whey proteins. This is mostly because of the taste. Per our testing criteria, taste carries the most weight. So despite a solid protein density and bang for your buck score, Six Star still scores lower comparatively. That said, taste is subjective, so you might feel different.

Price per serving:

Six Star has the most cost-effective price per serving of all whey proteins my team and I have reviewed:

Protein density:

Six Star is one of the least dense whey protein powders we’ve reviewed, which is part of the reason it costs less:

Calories per serving:

Six Star is also more caloric than most of its competitors:

Alternative products

If you’re looking for alternative whey proteins, check out the following:

My Final Thoughts

If you’re on a tight budget and looking to up your protein intake, Six Star Whey Protein is a decent option. At under $20 for 18 servings, with 30 grams of protein per scoop, it provides a good bang for your buck.

However, the lower price comes with some trade-offs. The taste and mixability of both vanilla and chocolate flavors were subpar, and the ingredient list contains fillers and artificial components I usually avoid.

If cost is your main concern and you’re not too picky about taste or ingredients, Six Star Whey Protein is worth a try. Otherwise, if you’re happy to pay a premium for higher quality ingredients and a better protein to calories ratio, check out some of the other options I’ve listed above.

If you found this review helpful, like and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more honest supplement reviews.

Let’s keep pushing forward on our fitness journeys, one scoop of protein at a time!

#1%BetterTogether